Haynes on Main in Mackinaw
Tonight was a little different from Groucho’s usual lunch-hour posts. For once I had a reason to have a drink and eat something other than tacos, so we headed to Mackinaw, Illinois, for Saturday night dinner at Haynes on Main.
Haynes on Main? Absolutely!
Patrick and Carol Haynes opened Haynes on Main in April 2013. They started with a much smaller footprint. What was once a small, single room bar, restaurant and kitchen has grown quite a bit. Now It boasts a size doubling patio, more space in the back, and a little gaming area.
Tonight we walked in to the hostess and were directed to a table in the main dining room. The OG seating. A tallboy table mounted to the raw brick wall, When they opened, this was was it. Sitting there, Margaret and I got to reminiscing about the early days. Back then, the bar had a flat-top griddle in the far left corner, and you could hear the sizzle of everything being cooked. Your Philly cheesesteak was chopped up on the griddle, and your burger was cooked right in front of you.
There wasn’t even a deep fryer back then. You couldn’t get French fries with anything, (yes, our Central Illinois sensibilities were shaken!) or anything deep-fried, for that matter. And it was pretty great. The burgers were amazing, everything was fresh, and it had a different vibe. I’d forgotten all about the old Burger of the Month board, too. The “Ghost Burger,” a double patty with ghost pepper cheese on a pretzel bun, was pretty amazing back in the day. They were tuned in to the craft beer crowd from the start, and I’ve really enjoyed going there over the years.
I’ll give Carol and Patrick credit: they’ve weathered every storm, from COVID on, whether that meant online cooking classes or collaborations with other chefs. They’ve always made an effort to bring something new and inventive to the little town of Mackinaw.
The Fall Cocktail Menu
Tonight we brought along friends from Pekin who’d never been there. We grabbed the seasonal cocktail menu, and every one of us got something different.
- Cider Donut Daiquiri (Captain Morgan Sliced Apple, cider, honey syrup, lemon and lime): This was mine, and it was amazing. My wife ended up ordering one too. Whatever they’re doing there, that’s how I want to drink cider from now on.
- Pink Lady (apple vodka, lemon, grenadine and a foam top): My friend George’s drink was very bitter and sour, but delicious, like a really potent lemonade.
- Pumpkin Spice Martini (pumpkin spice vodka, Irish cream and vanilla vodka): Andrea’s was creamy, milky goodness.
The glasses came rimmed with cinnamon sugar, and everything tasted like the holidays are around the corner, even if it was 70 degrees today!
Pizza and the Hot Honey Chicken
We grabbed a couple of 12-inch specialty pizzas. I got the Margherita, and it’s not traditional by any means: olive oil, fresh mozzarella, big slices of Roma tomato, fresh basil, and a balsamic glaze drizzled over the top. Very tasty. George went with the Haynes Deluxe: garlic parmesan sauce, sausage, mushrooms, onion, and banana peppers. Both pizzas were good, but a 12-inch is too much food for one person. I should remember that, because I always end up asking for a box to take home.
The women went for the Hot Honey Chicken sandwich, and I have to tell you, it’s money: breaded chicken, hot honey, pickle, and slaw piled on a brioche bun. There aren’t many tastier sandwiches around.
The Beer List
Going back to the craft beer side of things, their tap list is on Untappd, and the selection is pretty great. They’ve got local beer from Keg Grove and DESTIHL alongside the big macros, so you can get a Yuengling if that’s your flavor. I nearly ordered a Dragon’s Milk tonight, but I wasn’t sure how it would pair with the Margherita.
A Few Tips
- Go early. This place can get completely out of hand on weekend nights. We had four people and got seated pretty quickly, but if you’ve got a bigger group, call ahead.
- Watch Facebook for specials. Their social media presence is strong, and that’s where you’ll hear about things like their collaborations with Tato’s, when they team up on cronuts. When that happens, it’s a reason to run down there before they’re all gone.
Hitting on All Cylinders
Haynes on Main is one of those places every town wishes it had. The pricing is reasonable, the food selection is consistent but they have specials, and the atmosphere is great. It’s hitting on all cylinders.
How many times do you go to a place and think, “Man, this place is just missing something”? That’s never the case at Haynes. Tonight was a great night with great service, served up on Main Street in small-town Mackinaw, and it couldn’t have been more picturesque under a nearly full moon.
Haynes on Main
108 S Main St, Mackinaw, IL 61755
(309) 359-6246
Music in the Garden on Sundays, 2–5 p.m.
Website · Facebook · Instagram · Order online
Check Facebook for current hours and specials.
Cheers!





